< Back to other cases

ARYA VIJAY PUJARI V. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

Read the full judgement here
citation:

OA 1121/2022, 401/2023, 928/2023

court:

MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

judges:

JUSTICE MRIDULA BHATKAR & MRS. MEDHA GADGIL

ISSUE

Whether transgender persons are entitled to reservations in recruitment for Maharashtra Police? 

KEY FACTS 

Three applicants, Arya, Vinayak and Yashwant are transgender persons who wished to apply for posts in the Maharahstra Police. There was no option to apply as a transgender person in the form. They approached the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal. The Bombay High Court in State of Maharashtra v. Arya Vijay Pujari upheld a direction to include a transgender option in the recruitment and the state government issued a policy providing this in all public employment.  

They continued their application before the Tribunal requesting reservations for transgender persons. During the proceedings, the applicants had difficulty in qualifying for the physical examinations or other other evaluations. The government informed the Tribunal that out of 5.5 lakh government employees, there was not a single transgender person.

DECISION & REASONING 

The Tribunal noted that Maharashtra already provided 62% reservations for vertical categories, and it could not further breach the 50% limit on reservations. However, the Tribunal noted that full and effective participation of transgender persons required some positive discrimination. The Tribunal identified that the state government has such an obligation under the Supreme Court’s decision in NALSA v. Union of India, various High Court decisions and sections 3 and 8 of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019. 

So, the Tribunal held that the state must provide other forms of positive discrimination. The Tribunal directed the state to provide necessary grace marks or consider all transgender applicants who achieve 50%.  It also directed the State to provide another opportunity for those above the maximum age.

SIGNIFICANCE 

The order particularly recognises the dire lack of transgender persons in government employment. While it fails to direct the state to provide reservations as mandated by NALSA, it shows that the state is required to consider all forms of positive discrimination including concessions and relaxations in marks and age cutoffs.