< Back to other cases

STATE OF MAHARASHTRA V. ARYA VIJAY PUJARI

Read the full judgement here
citation:

WP 15037/2022

court:

BOMBAY HIGH COURT

judges:

CHIEF JUSTICE DIPANKAR DATTA & JUSTICE ABHAY AHUJA

ISSUE

Whether the Administrative Tribunal can direct the state to include transgender persons in police recruitment?

KEY FACTS

Arya and Nikita are two transgender persons who wish to apply for the post of police constable under the November 2022 recruitment notification. However, there was no option to apply as a transgender person in the form, which only had ‘male’ and ‘female’ options. Arya and Nikita approached the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal. The Tribunal, in an interim order, directed that such an option should be provided in this recruitment process as well as all recruitment done by the Home Department. The state appealed against this order before the High Court.

DECISION & REASONING

The Court held that the state must ensure a separate option for Arya, Nikita and all transgender persons in the ongoing recruitment process. However, the Tribunal could not direct the inclusion of such an option in all recruitment conducted by the Home Department. Instead, the Court directed the state to formulate a comprehensive policy for transgender persons as mandated under section 11(2) of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Rules, 2020 by 28th February 2023.

SIGNIFICANCE

The order affirms the right to a separate ‘transgender’ column in all recruitment. While it does not direct the state to provide this in all recruitment, it directed the State to frame such a policy by itself.