ISSUE
Whether the Rajasthan Government’s order including transgender persons within the Other Backward Classes (OBC) category without any separate horizontal reservation adequately fulfills the constitutional mandate laid down by the Supreme Court in NALSA?
KEY FACTS
Ganga Kumari, a transgender woman, approached the Rajasthan High Court seeking horizontal eaningful reservations for the transgender community. On the basis of NALSA v. Union of India and Ganga Kumari v. State of Rajasthan (II), the Rajasthan government notified the inclusion of transgender persons in the OBC list in 2023. Ganga argued that this failed to provide meaningful benefits to transgender persons. The Rajasthan government acknowledged that no transgender person had benefitted from reservations since 2023.
DECISION & REASONING
The Court stressed that the Supreme Court’s in NALSA directed governments to ‘extend all kinds of reservations’ to transgender persons. It cannot be illusory. Governments were also required to formulate welfare measures under section 8 of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019. The current policy failed to provide any actual benefit to transgender people, and those who belonged to SC, ST and SEBC categories were forced to choose between their constitutional entitlements based on their caste/tribe and their gender. So, the Court held that inclusion in the OBC list was insufficient to fulfil the constitutional objective of substantive equality.
The Court also acknowledged that transgender persons are a small percentage of the population and only the government can enact reservation policy, not the judiciary. So, the Court directed the government to constitute a committee to look at the disadvantages faced by transgender persons across different social categories and frame an appropriate reservation policy. The Court strongly recommended a policy along the lines of the Karnataka Civil Services (General Recruitment) (Amendment) Rules, 2021 which provided 1% horizontal reservations across caste categories for transgender persons in public employment.
As an interim measure, the Court directed the government to provide an additional weightage of 3% of the maximum marks in any recruitment and admissions conducted by State, funded or aided institutions.
SIGNIFICANCE
The judgment acknowledged that transgender persons belonging to SC, ST, and SEBC categories experience overlapping forms of marginalisation and are entitled to affirmative action on both grounds. It marks the third judgment that explicitly recommends state government to formulate horizontal reservation policies, after Sangama v. State of Karnataka and Rakshika Raj v. State of Tamil Nadu.
Originally, an epilogue authored by Justice Monga noted that the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act, 2026 that was passed just before the judgment departed from the constitutional principle of self-determined gender identity. It stated that the government must, to the extent possible follow this principle within the contours of amended law. However, on a clarification application, the court removed these remarks, stating that they were neither ‘intended nor necessary’.