< Back to other cases

GANGA KUMARI V. STATE OF RAJASTHAN (II)

Read the full judgement here
citation:

CIVIL WP 10672/2021

court:

RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT

judges:

JUSTICES MANINDRA MOHAN SHRIVASTAVA & MADAN GOPAL VYAS

ISSUE

Whether the Rajasthan government is required to provide reservations for transgender persons?

KEY FACTS

Ganga Kumari, a transgender person belonging to an OBC community, had earlier received a High Court judgment in her favour, directing her appointment to the post of Woman Police Constable on the basis of self-identification. Ganga later approached the High Court seeking an order for comprehensive 1% horizontal reservation policy under the Rajasthan Police Subordinate Service Rules, 1989. The Court also held that Ganga can apply as a ‘third gender’ candidate in recruitment as an interim measure.

DECISION & REASONING

The High Court held that the Supreme Court’s directive in NALSA v. Union of India was clear. All transgender persons are entitled to reservations and in educational institutions and public appointments. It casts an obligation on the state to work out the manner and extent of reservations required based on available date. The Court directed the State to conduct the necessary exercise and issue the required rules or legislation within 4 months.

SIGNIFICANCE

The judgment clarifies that NALSA is binding on all state governments with respect to implementing reservations for transgender persons. The Rajasthan government issued a notification dated 12.01.2023 including transgender persons in the state’s OBC list. The Court held that such vertical reservations were illusory and recommended horizontal reservations in Ganga Kumari v. State of Rajasthan (III).