ISSUE
Whether a village panchayat can pass a resolution against land allocations for transgender persons in the village?
KEY FACTS
The District Collector of Cuddalore sought to allocate land under a welfare scheme near the Nainarkuppam Village bus stop to transgender persons. Following this, the Village Panchayat passed a resolution stating that no patta (land allotment) would be given to transgender persons in the village. The Collector issued a show-cause notice to the President of the Panchayat under the Tamil Nadu Panchayats Act, 1994. The Panchayat responded to the Collector claiming transgender persons would destroy the village’s culture, and affect the future of students who used the bus stop.
The President filed a petition at the High Court arguing that only poor inhabitants of the village should receive pattas under government schemes.
DECISION & REASONING
The Court refused to allow the President to withdraw his petition because the resolution was unconstitutional.
The Court cited the legal recognition of transgender persons in NALSA v. Union of India and the prohibition of discrimination under section 3 of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019. The Court dismissed the President’s attempt to argue that benefits should be restricted to poor inhabitants of the village as an attempt to circumvent the Panchayat’s illegal resolution.
The Court noted the social ostracisation of transgender people. It also considered the failure of the executive’s ‘bottom rung’ to implement the State’s welfare measures for transgender persons. Transgender people should be able to speak about their own rights. The Court recognised their right to reservations as a socially backward class. So, the Court directed the Tamil Nadu government to initiate steps to provide reservations for transgender persons in local body elections.
The Court dismissed the President’s petition. It directed the Collector to initiate proceedings to remove the President and members of the Panchayat. It also directed that eligible transgender persons should be allotted free house site pattas and permitted to participate in village festivals and religious institutions.
SIGNIFICANCE
The judgment shows that social beliefs and conventions can only change with political participation and representation of transgender persons’ interests. The Court therefore explicitly recognised a legal right to reservations in law-making institutions for transgender persons. The judgment also shows that prejudice against transgender people is grounds for disciplinary action.