ISSUE
Whether Hari Devageeth, a transgender man, can preserve his fertility by cryopreserving his oocytes under the Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021 (‘ART Act’), before undergoing gender affirmation surgery?
KEY FACTS
Hari is a transgender man who has begun undergoing hormone replacement therapy and has also undergone a mastectomy as gender affirmation surgery. Based on these medical interventions, he has also received a transgender identity card and certificate as a ‘man’ under section 7 of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 (‘Trans Act’). Before undergoing a complete hysterectomy to affirm his gender, Hari wished to preserve his oocytes and approached an Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Clinic. The Clinic refused, citing the absence of any provision in the ART Act which permitted the cryopreservation of oocytes of transgender persons. Instead, it was claimed that the benefits of the ART Act are limited to ‘women’ and ‘commissioning couples’. Since Hari is a man, he is unable to access ART procedures. Hari apporached the Court and claimed that the denial of cryopreservation services violated his fundamental rights, specifically articles 14, 15, and 21.
DECISION & REASONING
The Kerala High Court held that since Hari is a transgender man whose reproductive organs remained intact, he is permitted to preserve his oocytes at any ART bank before completing his gender reassignment surgery.
The Court noted that under section 2(1)(u) of the ART Act, only a ‘woman’ could access ART. Since Hari’s petition did not formally challenge these provisions, the Court held that it could not strike it down. So, the constitutionality of the provision was left open to future proceedings.
However, the Court held that the right to reproductive choices is protected under the right to privacy and the right to life with dignity under article 21 of the Constitution. The Court noted that the ART Act does not define a ‘woman’. Because of the nature of ART, only a ‘biological woman’ whose uterus is intact, has fallopian tubes and ovaries can freeze eggs. The Court also drew on dictionary definitions of woman as an adult human female to define a ‘biological woman’. So, the Court established a distinction between self-perceived gender identity and biological sex for the purpose of the ART Act. Hari may have documents showing his gender identity as male, but he retained ‘female’ reproductive organs. He fell under under the definition of ‘woman’ under the ART Act.
The Court also criticised the lack of a health manual on sex reassignment surgeries which is mandated by section 15(d) of the Trans Act. Hari was not given comprehensive information about his options to preserve fertility before his gender affirming procedures.
SIGNIFICANCE
The case drew a distinction between a transgender person’s ‘biological sex’ and self-perceived gender identity for the purpose of biological reproductive rights. Through the Court’s reasoning, transgender men are able to exercise reproductive rights that statute may restrict to ‘women’. While the judgment ensures greater access to procedures like cryopreservation of oocytes, it requires transgender men to be defined as ‘women’, which undermines the legal recognition of their self-determined gender identity.