< Back to other cases

BHUPESH THAKUR V. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH

citation:

2024:HHC:7806 |

court:

HIMACHAL PRADESH HIGH COURT

judges:

JUSTICE SANDEEP SHARMA

ISSUE 

Whether the offence of sexual intercourse by employing deceitful means can apply to cases where the victim is a transgender woman? 

KEY FACTS 

The complainant was a transgender person, who had female on her Aadhaar card. She alleged that the defendant had promised to marry her. During the course of their relationship, they had sexual relations. However, the defendant and his father had pressured her to undergo sex reassignment surgery before marriage. After completing the surgery, the defendant refused to proceed with the marriage and instead fixed a marriage with another woman.

The complainant registered an FIR. The allegations include sexual intercourse by deceitful means or a false promise of marriage under section 69 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) and abuse of a transgender person under section 18(d) of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 (Trans Act). The defendant approached the High Court for interim bail.

DECISION & REASONING 

The Court considered the defendant’s bail application. The Court considered that section 69 of the BNS only applies if the victim is a woman. Section 2(10) of the BNS recognises ‘male, female or transgender’ and states that the definition of transgender under section 2(k) of the Trans Act would apply. Section 2(35) defines a ‘woman’ as a ‘female human being’. So, the Court held that the BNS classifies transgender persons as a separate category from women, and section 69 would not apply since the complainant is a transgender person.

Instead, the Court confirmed that section 18(d) of the Trans Act could apply in her case. This has a maximum punishment of two years compared to ten years under section 69 of the BNS. The Court also noted there was no evidence of sexual intercourse taking place after the complainant’s sex reassignment surgery. Following this analysis, since the defendant had cooperated with the investigation, the Court affirmed the principle of innocent until proven guilty and granted bail with certain conditions. 

SIGNIFICANCE 

The judgment applies to bail and does not determine the outcome of the complaint. However, it interprets the BNS in a way that ignores the principle of self-determination. The Court considered when the complainant underwent sex reassignment surgery to determine her gender at the time and did not consider her Aadhaar card.