ISSUE
Whether members of the kinnar (a transgender) community have a fundamental right to collect badhai (customary offerings) in a defined territory? And whether the courts can direct the authorities to demarcate that territory to protect the right?
KEY FACTS
The petitioner, Rekha Devi, belongs to the kinnar community residing in the jurisdiction of the Colonelganj Police Station in the Gonda district in Uttar Pradesh. The kinnar community she is part of have been collecting badhai, customary offerings given on auspicious occasions, in a defined territory for many years. However, Rekha claims that other kinnars in Gonda have recently begun to encroach on their collection territory leading to violence within the community. Rekha filed a petition asking the Allahabad High Court to recognise their customary/jajmani rights and demarcate boundaries for collecton of badhai.
DECISION & REASONING
The Court held that there is no legal basis or right to collect money. simply because it may be a long-standing practice. There is no provision of the Constitution or the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 to support this. The Court also took note of the ‘major departure’ that the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act, 2026 would make. The Court reasoned that granting such a right to one group of kinnars could embolden others to extract money illegally, which is an offence under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023. The petition was therefore dismissed.
SIGNIFICANCE
The order holds that customary practices like badhai among transgender communities like the kinnars cannot become legally enforceable. Disputes and violence between communities were left to be handled by the criminal law rather than through adjudication of collection territory.