ISSUE
Whether the Court should direct the Tamil Nadu Nurses and Midwives Council to record the petitioner’s gender as just ‘male’ and issue a no-objection certificate to allow him to register with the Karnataka State Nursing Council?
KEY FACTS
The petitioner, a transgender man, has changed all his documents to hold the gender ‘male’. He holds an identity card from the Tamil Nadu Transgender Welfare Board as well as an identity card and certificate issued by the District Magistrate under section 7 of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 (‘Trans Act’). He has undergone gender affirmation surgery and his Aadhaar, PAN Card, driving license and other documents have also been changed to reflect his gender as ‘male’.
However, when the he attempted to transfer his registration with the Tamil Nadu Nurses and Midwives Council to the Karnataka State Nursing Council, he was described in their communication as a ‘transgender man’. He approached the Madras High Court requesting a direction to strike out the term ‘transgender’ from his documentation and only reflect ‘man’ or ‘male’.
DECISION & REASONING
The Court relied on Section 7 of the Trans Act and held that once the petitioner had received his final certificate as ‘male’ under the Trans Act, every authority was obliged to carry out the gender change. Further, the Court held Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (retired) v. Union of India made it clear that the right to construct one’s own gender identity fell within the ambit of the right to privacy. So, the Court directed the Tamil Nadu Nurses and Midwives Council to strike out all mentions of the petitioner being transgender, or even ‘transgender male’. His records should only have ‘male’.
SIGNIFICANCE
The Madras High Court’s decision affirms that once an individual has completed their legal transition, they have a right to keep their transgender history and identity private.