< Back to other cases

VISHAL V. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

Read the full judgement here
citation:

2026:BHC-NAG:15063

court:

BOMBAY HIGH COURT (NAGPUR BENCH)

judges:

JUSTICE MEHROZ K. PATHAN

ISSUE

Whether a transgender woman can be the victim of the offences of sexual harassment against a woman and abuse against a transgender person, despite having no transgender certificate at the time of the alleged crime?

KEY FACTS

The complainant, is a transgender woman. She had undertaken hormone therapy since 2015 and wore women’s clothes since 2021. She alleged that Vishal, an Agniveer in the Indian Army, ha forcibel sexual intercourse with her, on the pretext of marriage on 28.10.2025, and again on 30.10.2025 when he also verbally abused her. An FIR was registered, among other things, for sexual harassment of a woman under section 75 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (‘BNS’) and abuse against a transgender person under section 18(d) of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 (‘Trans Act’). Vishal applied for discharge from the trial court. He argued that these crimes were against a ‘woman’ and a ‘transgender person’ respectively, and the complainant was neither at the time. The BNS defines woman as a female human being and she only obtained a transgender certificate on 12.02.2026, after the incidents.

DECISION

The Court noted that section 2(k) of the Trans Act recognises transgender men and women whether or not they have undergone surgery or hormone therapy. Further, NALSA v. Union of India and section 4(2) of the Tans Act recognise one’s self-perceived identity. So, the Court held that the absence of a certificate on the dates of the incidents did not bar prosecution under section 18(d) for sexual abuse of a transgender person. The Court extended this reasoning to hold that the complainant was a woman based on her self-perception. Section 2(k) of the Trans Act clearly recognised transgender women as one of the identities within the definition. So, the Court held that the charge under section 75 of the BNS could also proceed.

The Court noted that the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act, 2026, which received assent on 30.03.2026, omitted Section 4(2). However, it was still in force on the dates of the incidents and of the FIR. Since the complainant identified as a woman, had undergone hormonal treatment and had since obtained a certificate of identity, her self-identification could not be questioned at the discharge stage. So, the Court dismissed Vishal’s petition.

SIGNIFICANCE

The judgment held that a transgender woman who identifies as a woman can be the victim of offences against women, such as sexual harassment under Section 75 of the BNS, and that the criminal protection of the 2019 Act does not depend on holding a certificate of identity.