ISSUE
Whether a transgender woman is entitled to have her gender recorded as ‘Female’ on her citizenship certificate and other identity documents based on her self-perceived gender identity, and to have her dead name and earlier gender details kept confidential?
KEY FACTS
The petitioner, Rukshana Kapali, is a transgender woman. She was assigned male at birth and received all her documents under her dead name and gender. After finishing school she adopted the name Rukshana and began living as a woman. In 2015, she applied for a citizenship certificate as ‘Female’. The authorities marked her gender as ‘Other’ instead, and asked for medical or other evidence that she was female. Further, Tribhuvan University refused to process her registration form, blocking her higher education.
While she had several documents showing her identity as ‘female’, her citizenship certificate and birth certificate still reflect ‘Other’. Rukshana approached the Supreme Court seeking recognition as ‘Female’ and confidentiality of her dead name.
DECISION & REASONING
The Court held that Rukshana can approach the Court directly when the Citizenship Act and the rules on correcting documents contain no procedure for changing gender.
The Court relied on the rights to equality, dignity, privacy and education in the Constitution of Nepal, its decision in Sunil Babu Pant v. Government of Nepal and international human rights law. It held that a person has the right to determine their gender identity based on self-perception rather than biological sex. Further, the Court recognised gender identity and sexual orientation as protected grounds on which discrimination is prohibited under Article 18. The Court directed authorities to ensure her citizenship certificate and other personal identification documents shall reflect her gender as ‘Female’. It also held that the denial of higher education violated her rights to equality and education.
The Court also held that while the State may maintain records, under the Privacy Act, 2075 (2018 AD) and the right to privacy, Rukshana’s dead name and gender identity in her birth certificate must remain confidential. Its disclosure has caused her humiliation and discrimination.
SIGNIFICANCE
The judgment affirmed that legal recognition of gender rests on self-perception and not on medical evidence. It extends this right to have one’s self-identified gender on every document, not just as ‘Other’ but as ‘Female’. It also recognised the right for a transgender person to keep their dead name and previous legal gender confidential.