< Back to other cases

S. TAMILSELVI V. HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE DEPARTMENT

Read the full judgement here
citation:

WP 26505/2022

court:

MADRAS HIGH COURT

judges:

JUSTICE R. SURESH KUMAR

ISSUE

Whether the Directorate of Medical Educations’ prospectus which only provides for male and female merit lists, but not transgender persons is unlawful? And whether there must be a special category of transgender persons for the petitioner?

s unlawful for prospectus for the Post Basic B.Sc. (Nursing) and Post Basic Diploma in Psychiatric Nursing courses for 2022-23 is unlawful illegal for not categorising transgender persons under a special category, and whether the petitioner must be admitted under that category

KEY FACTS

The petitioner, S. Tamilselvi, was assigned male at birth and identifies as a transgender woman. She underwent gender affirmation surgery in 2015, changed her name and published the change in the Tamil Nadu Government Gazette in 2017.

In a previous case, she had already received an order from the Court to consider her admission as a transgender person in 2018 for a Diploma in Nursing Course for Women.

The prospectus for the 2022-23 intake of the Post Basic B.Sc. (Nursing) course also did not make any provision for transgender students. It set apart certain seats for men and some for women. Tamilselvi applied under the MBC quota. In the provisional merit list, she was ranked among female non-service candidates and placed at No. 280.

She filed a writ petition before the Madras High Court seeking to quash the prospectus to the extent it did not recognise transgender persons as a special category, and a direction to admit her under that category. The state government argued that if they provided transgender reservations and there are not enough candidates, the seats may be wasted.

DECISION & REASONING

The Court held that the law requires the recognition of transgender persons in all recruitment. It relied on NALSA v. Union of India and K. Prithika Yashini v. TNUSRB, and on sections 4, 8 and 13 of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019.

The Court noted that the prospectus need not set aside transgender seats, but could have a note stating that if transgender persons apply, they will be considered under a special category. Placing Tamilselvi in the women’s merit list was not just an omission, it was contrary to established law. So, the Court directed the Directorate of Medical Education to make a separate merit list for transgender persons and consider Tamilselvi’s application under that category.

SIGNIFICANCE

The judgment confirms that when admissions are conducted on a gendered basis, there must be a separate category for transgender persons. The number of transgender candidates cannot determine the existence of the category.