ISSUE
Whether the State is obliged to provide reservations to transgender persons in education and public employment?
KEY FACTS
Aneera Kabeer C. is a transgender person and an aspirant for government employment. Aneera filed writ petitions before the Kerala High Court asking for a direction to the Kerala government to provide reservations in education and public employment. She filed the first petition in 2019 and the Court passed various interim orders, but no effective reservation followed.
The government has issued several orders creating welfare schemes for transgender persons since 2015, and framed rules under the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 (Trans Act) in 2020. However, it has not evolved any policy of reservation for any public recruitment notification.
DECISION & REASONING
The Court acknowledged that it ordinarily does not interfere in matters of policy. It held, however, that when the Supreme Court has given clear directions, continued government inaction must be addressed. In NALSA v. Union of India (2014), the Supreme Court had directed the Centre and States to extend reservations in admissions and public appointments and education to transgender persons. It also referred to section 3 of the Trans Act, which prohibits discrimination in education, employment and other areas. Groups facing structural and societal disadvantages cannot be expected to compete on equal footing under the Indian Constitution. The Court directed the Government to implement reservations for transgender persons within six months of receiving a copy of the judgment.
SIGNIFICANCE
The judgment holds that high courts can compel the implementation of an affirmative action for transgender persons. It marks a key step towards reservations in the state of Keralam.