< Back to other cases

YASHIKA (@ASHISH KUMAR) V. PANJAB UNIVERSITY, CHANDIGARH

Read the full judgement here
citation:

CWP 5782/2022

court:

PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT

judges:

JUSTICE SUDHIR MITTAL

ISSUE

Whether non-availability of hostels violates equality rights of transgender students? And whether Transgender Welfare Boards must meet frequently and take action on issues of discrimination?

KEY FACTS

Yashika is a transgender woman student at Panjab University. However, she was denied hostel accommodation because of her transgender identity. Yashika approached the Union Territory Administration but received no relief. Failing this, she approached the High Court. She was then temporarily placed in the faculty house and allowed to eat at the Working Women’s Hostel.

DECISION & REASONING

In its first interim order, the Court stated that Panjab University is an autonomous body and does not need to wait for UGC or Union Territory Administration guidelines to accommodate transgender persons. 

In its second interim order, the Court noted that the denial of a hostel had violated Yashika’s right against discrimination and her right to access education on par with others. It also noted that Yashika was forced to come to Court because the Union Territory Administration did not respond. It recommended that the Transgender Welfare Board should be held more frequently so that issues likely to arise in the future can be anticipated. 

The case was dismissed in the final order since the issue was resolved by providing Yashika place in the Working Women’s Hostel.

SIGNIFICANCE

The Court affirmed that appropriate hostel facilities are required for transgender persons under the right to equality and education. It also emphatically stated that it was essential that the Transgender Welfare Board ‘acquire teeth’ and do not remain ‘cosmetic features’.