< Back to other cases

VITHAL MANIK KHATRI V. SAGAR SANJAY KAMBLE @ SAKSHI VITHAL KHATRI

Read the full judgement here
citation:

WP 4037/2021

court:

BOMBAY HIGH COURT

judges:

JUSTICE AMIT BORKAR

ISSUE

Whether a transgender woman who has undergone sex reassignment surgery can qualify as an “aggrieved person” under the Domestic Violence Act, 2005 and claim maintenance under the Act?

KEY FACTS

The respondent, Sakshi Vithal Khatri, was a transgender woman who underwent sex reassignment surgery in June 2016 and subsequently married the petitioner, Vithal Manik Khatri, the next month. In 2018, Sakshi filed an application under the Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (‘DV Act’), seeking interim maintenance. The civil Judicial Magistrate First Class ordered Vithal to pay ₹12,000 per month as interim maintenance in November 2019. Vithal appealed to the Additional Sessions Judge against this order, who dismissed the appeal. So, Vithal approached the Bombay High Court, arguing that Sakshi did not qualify as an aggrieved person since she was not a “woman”. Sakshi did not have a transgender certificate under Section 7 of the Transgender Persons Act, 2019.

DECISION & REASONING

The Bombay High Court dismissed Vithal’s petition and upheld the interim maintenance of ₹12,000 per month. Relying on NALSA v. Union of India, the Court emphasised that transgender persons have the right to receive legal recognition as their self-determined gender identity. Further, the aim of the DV Act is to protect women from domestic abuse in line with the right to equality and the right to life with dignity. It should be given a broad interpretation. Therefore, the Court held that “woman” under section 2(a) of the DV Act  includes transgender women who have undergone sex reassignment surgery.

SIGNIFICANCE

The judgment recognised that the protections for women in the context of domestic violence extends to all women including transgender women. It confirms the right to self-determine one’s gender identity in the context of gendered legislation.