< Back to other cases

SPECIAL DETERMINATION ON THE PENAL CODE AMENDMENT BILL 2023 (DECRIMINALISATION)

Read the full judgement here
citation:

SC SD 13/2023

court:

SRI LANKA SUPREME COURT

judges:

CHIEF JUSTICE JAYANTHA JAYASURIYA AND JUSTICES VIJITH MALALGODA & ARJUNA OBEYESEKERE

ISSUE

Whether the Penal Code (Amendment) Bill, 2023 which decriminalises homosexual intimacy can be passed as an ordinary law and is consistent with the Constitution of Sri Lanka? 

KEY FACTS 

Member of Parliament Premanath C. Dolewatta introduced a private member’s Bill titled Penal Code (Amendment) Bill, 2023 (‘the Bill’). The Bill seeks to repeal sections 365 and 365A of the Sri Lankan Penal Code, which criminalise ‘unnatural carnal intercourse’ and ‘gross indecency’ including all homosexual intimacy.

Three petitioners requested a determination from the Supreme Court that the Bill was inconsistent with the Constitution. They argued it should require 2/3rds majority and approval by a referendum to pass as a constitutional amendment.

DECISION & REASONING 

The Court held that the petitioners objections to the Bill were based on conjecture and rejected them. There was no justified connection between the criminalisation of homosexuality and the protection of children or the prevalance of HIV/AIDS. Since decriminalisation is unlikely to harm life, limb or property and is a matter of morality, Parliaments have the power to amend the law.

The Court also referred to its prior decisions and decisions in landmark cases in other countries, including Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India. It held that LGBTQ+ persons are entitled to human dignity and privacy under the Constitution and human rights treaties.

Therefore, the Court held that Parliament may pass the Bill as an ordinary law.

SIGNIFICANCE

The judgment reinforced that human dignity is closely associated with sexuality and identity and cannot be infringed for safeguarding ‘morality’. The landmark ruling clears the way for Parliament to consider the issue of decriminalisation of homosexuality and amend its law. The provisions of section 365 and 365A continue to be used against all gender and sexual minorities, including transgender persons.