< Back to other cases

S. MANI V. HOME, PROHIBITION AND EXCISE DEPARTMENT

Read the full judgement here
citation:

WP 29354/2025

court:

MADRAS HIGH COURT

judges:

JUSTICE G.K. ILANTHIRAIYAN

ISSUE

Whether the petitioner, who was appointed as a Male Nursing Assistant was entitled to be appointed as a Female Nursing Assistant after she underwent gender affirmation surgery?

KEY FACTS

The petitioner was appointed as a Male Nursing Assistant at the Central Prison in Cuddalore in February 2021. In March 2023, she underwent gender affirmation surgery as a transgender person. She informed the Prison Superintendent she was unable to perform her duties as a male nursing assistant.

The petitioner was then directed to go on leave and on returning, was not allowed to resume her duty as a nursing assistant. She stopped receiving a salary in December 2024. In June 2025, she requested that she be transferred to the Government Hospital, Cuddalore, where there was a vacancy for Female Nursing Assistant. Receiving no response, she approached the Madras High Court.

DECISION & REASONING

The Court acknowledged that once she had undergone surgery and became transgender, she could no longer perform her duties as a male nursing assistant. Since there was a Female Nursing Assistant post vacant, the Court directed the State of Tamil Nadu to depute the petitioner to that post. The Court also required her salary arrears to be paid within 2 weeks.

SIGNIFICANCE

While the judgment does not directly discuss statutory or constitutional provisions, it sets a clear precedent for government employees who undergo gender affirmative surgery. The Court went beyond directing the State to consider the petitioner’s representation. It directly ordered her appointment in a post for the appropriate gender and the payment of her salary. It specifically rejects the Police Superintendent’s argument that a transgender person cannot be employed anywhere after surgery.