< Back to other cases

R. ANUSHRI V. TAMIL NADU PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION

Read the full judgement here
citation:

WP 11197/2018

court:

MADRAS HIGH COURT

judges:

JUSTICE V. BHAVANI SUBBAROYAN

ISSUE

Whether transgender persons applying for public employment can be ranked along with men or women from their caste, instead of being ranked under a special category?

KEY FACTS

The petitioner, R. Anushri, was a transgender woman from the Scheduled Caste (‘SC’) category. In 2017, she applied for a post advertised by the Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission (‘TNPSC’). She listed her gender as ‘transgender’. She scored 121.5 marks in the written examination, above the qualifying mark of 90 for all categories. The TNPSC considered her application under the ‘Schedule Caste (Women)’ category, for which the cut-off was 222 marks. Hence, Anushri was not called.  

Anushri challenged the recruitment process, and asked for provisional admission. Anushri argued that there were candidates in special categories who had scored lower marks than she had and she should also be considered under a special category. The TNPSC argued that it could not treat transgender persons under the special category without instructions from the state government.  

DECISION & REASONING

The Court relied on the Supreme Court’s judgment in NALSA v. Union of India (‘NALSA’) which directed governments to provide reservations for transgender. As per the Court, the judgment did not require declaring transgender persons as a backward class, but to extend reservations that backward classes receive. It also held that NALSA required governments to consider transgender persons as distinct from male and female. TNPSC’s recruitment notification did not provide any reservations or special category for transgender persons despite the judgment in NALSA and the High Court’s order in The Chairman v. Aradhana. 

The Court directed the state government to treat transgender persons as a special category, rather than under male or female categories, in all education and employment. It also directed the government to prescribe separate norms below those for male and female candidates, including cuto-off marks, age relaxations and other concessions. Since the vacancies for the 2017-2018 recruitment had been filled, the Court TNSPC to be given first preference in the ongoing 2022 recruitment. . 

SIGNIFICANCE

The Court’s reasoning ensures that transgender candidates in public employment are given priority based on their gender identity under a special category. The use of a special category, however, may not result in adequately accounting for the intersection of caste for transgender persons, and may force transgender men and women within the binary to be placed on a separate rank list.