< Back to other cases

PODILI SIVA MURALI V. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH

Read the full judgement here
citation:

WP 25275/2020

court:

ANDHRA PRADESH HIGH COURT

judges:

JUSTICE M. SATHYANARAYAN MURTHY

ISSUE

Whether a State housing scheme for houseless persons that only allotted sites in the name of women, violated the right to equality for men and transgender persons?

KEY FACTS

The petitioners, Podili Siva Murali and 128 others, were largely male houseless residents of Tenali living below the poverty line. Under its ‘Navaratnalu – Pedalandariki Illu’ scheme, the Andhra Pradesh government set out to distribute 25 lakh house site pattas to the homeless poor. Further, Guideline 2 under the Government Order for the scheme (Ms.No.367 dated 19.08.2019) required every patta to be issued in the name of the woman of the household. The petitioners challenged this order and two later Government Orders, arguing among other things that the scheme ignored eligible male widowers and transgender persons (whom the judgment calls ‘transsexuals’). The State defended the allotment as a special provision for women under Article 15(3) that benefited the whole family. 

DECISION

The Court relied on Articles 14, 15(1), 15(3) and 39. It held that the object of the scheme was to house the homeless poor and not to empower women, so allotting every site to women was not rationally justified by the objective of the scheme. Further, special provisions for women under Article 15(3) that amounted to 100% reservations would be unreasonable when balanced against the general principle of equality under Article 15(1).

On the exclusion of transgender persons, specifically the Court relied on NALSA v. Union of India. The Court noted that many transgender persons live below the poverty line without shelter and the State had made no provision for their housing even though they are entitled to equal protection of the laws. It held their exclusion violated Article 14 and international conventions on equality. The Court also noted the direction in NALSA that governments must frame social welfare schemes for transgender persons.

So, the Court quashed Guideline 2 of the Government Order and directed the State to allot house sites to men and transgender persons on par with women, subject to their eligibility.

SIGNIFICANCE

The judgment held that leaving transgender persons out of a State welfare scheme for the poor denies them equal protection under the Constitution, and read NALSA as obliging the State to include them in schemes for housing. It reached this finding in a challenge brought by houseless men, and no petitioner was a transgender person.