< Back to other cases

NADEEM UL ZAFAR KHAN V. RETURNING OFFICER, NA-47

Read the full judgement here
citation:

EA 50-51/2024

court:

ISLAMABAD HIGH COURT

judges:

JUSTICE ARBAB MUHAMMAD TAHIR

ISSUE 

Whether a transgender person is legally permitted to contest elections for general seats of Pakistan’s National Assembly? 

KEY FACTS 

The appellant, Nadeem, filed an election appeal challenging the nomination of a transgender person, Nayab Ali, who was accepted to stand in the NA-47 and NA-46 constituencies. Nadeem was not a registered voter in either constituency and he had not filed written objections to the Returning Officers. The Federal Shariat Court’s judgment in Hammad Hussain v. Federation of Pakistan declared that provisions of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2018 (Trans Act) violated injunctions of Islam. Following this, the National Database & Registration Authority (NADRA) had issued a notification suspending new Computerised National Identity Cards (CNIC), which are given to all adult Pakistani citizens, for transgender persons. Nadeem alleged that as a result, transgender persons should not be permitted to contest elections. 

DECISION & REASONING 

The Court rejected Nadeem’s appeal and allowed Nayab Ali to contest elections.

It held that Article 51 of the Constitution of Pakistan, which outlines the qualifications for membership of the National Assembly, allows all citizens to contest elections and is framed in a gender-neutral manner. Transgender persons cannot be made stateless by revoking a CNIC unless a competent authority determines their citizenship. The NADRA notification never applied to CNICs already issued including Nayab Ali’s. It had only paused new CNICs with the ‘X’ gender marker.

Further, under Article 203D(2) of the Pakistani Constitution, the effect of Federal Shariat Court judgments will be suspended if it is taken on appeal. Since an appeal against Hammad Hussain, is pending before the Shariat Appellate Bench of the Pakistani Supreme Court, it is currently suspended. As a result, the NADRA notification had also been revoked and they had continued issuing CNIC cards for transgender persons with an ‘X’ gender marker.

The Court also ruled that since Nadeem was not a voter in NA-47 or NA-46 and had failed to file written objections before the Returning Officers, his appeal was not maintainable under election laws.

SIGNIFICANCE 

The judgment established that constitutional qualifications for participating in elections to general seats in the National Assembly are gender neutral, affirming the right of transgender citizens to run for public office. It also confirms that Hammad Hussain has no effect and the Trans Act remains in force.