ISSUE
Whether the National Law School of India University is required by law to provide reservation in admission and financial assistance for transgender persons in its three-year LLB programme?
KEY FACTS
The petitioner, Mugil Anbu Vasantha, is a transgender man. He has completed his change of name and gender through an affidavit and gazette advertisement as ‘transgender’. In 2023, Mugil applied for admission to the three-year LLB programme at the National Law School of India University (‘NLSIU’), but was denied admission. Mugil secured the 62nd position in the general category merit list, while the candidate on the 40th position was the last selected candidate. Mugil submitted representations to NLSIU but it NLSIU did not take action.
On 22.8.2023, the High Court directed NLSIU to admit Mugil on an interim basis. Consequently, Mugil was granted admission, for which the first-year fee was ₹3,75,500. Mugil could only pay ₹50,000 because of loss of family support and ineligibility for education loans. NLSIU provided Mugil with partial financial aid, but refused to permit Mugil to attend classes. Mugil’s admission lapsed because of the non-payment of fees.
DECISION & REASONING
The Karnataka High Court cited several High Court orders that had issued directions for providing reservations to transgender persons in admissions to educational institutions and in employment. There, governments and authorities had not implemented the directions for reservations and adequate welfare measures issued by the Supreme Court in NALSA v Union of India.
NLSIU argued that under the National Law School of India University Act, 1986, reservations could only be provided by its Executive Council. The Court found that NLSIU had not explained any steps taken towards providing reservation and suitable financial aid for transgender persons. Hence, the Court held that NLSIU’s admission and financial aid policies discriminated against transgender persons, and deprived them from pursuing the three-year LLB programme. The Court dismissed NLSIU’s arguments as technical.
However, the Court acknowledged that it cannot direct a specific percentage of reservation. So, it directed NLSIU to frame a reservation policy in the next academic year. Until then, as an interim measure, it directed NLSIU to provide 0.5% reservation and fee waiver for transgender students. Mugil would be admitted under this interim direction if no other transgender person sought admission. The Court also directed the State government to frame a reservation and fee reimbursement policy for transgender persons.
SIGNIFICANCE
The judgment affirms that NALSA’s direction to implement reservations creates a legal mandates on all governments and state institutions. The judgment also clarifies that to make such reservations effective, it must acknowledge the circumstances of transgender persons and provide the required financial assistance to access education.
NLSIU has taken this judgment an appeal before a two-judge bench of the High Court. On appeal, the Court requested the state government to look into providing Mugil admission and financial aid for an LLB programme in other state law colleges so he does not experience further delay. As a result, the Court has ordered the government to admit and provide hostel accommodation and financial aid to study at Seshadaripuram Law College. Prompted by these proceedings, the state government has implemented 1% horizontal reservation across Karnataka State Law University college admissions
READ THE INTERIM ORDERS BY THE TWO-JUDGE BENCH HERE.