ISSUE
Whether a couple including a man and a woman with an intersex condition are entitled to avail gestational surrogacy under the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021?
KEY FACTS
The petitioners include a woman who has Complete Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (CAIS) and her husband. Upon chromosome analysis, the petitioner was seen to have 46 XY karyotype categorised as ‘intersex’. She lived her life as a healthy woman, but does not have ovaries or a uterus. Hence, the petitioners decided to apply for gestational surrogacy as a couple under the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021.
The petitioners received a certificate of medical necessity and a magistrate’s order for parentage. However, the authority assigned as the Board to check for eligibility under the Act refused the application. The authority noted that the Central Government has clarified that transgender persons do not qualify under the Act. The petitioners challenged this order before the Telangana High Court.
DECISION & REASONING
The Court relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in Arun Muthivel v. Union of India. It held that the objective of the Act was to allow childless couples, particularly those with ‘rare disorders’, to be rid of the social stigma of infertility in Hindu and Indian marriages. The Court noted that the wife in this case had a disorder of sex development (DSD), which can also be described as a variation in sex characteristics or an intersex condition. However, the Court noted that she was a woman and not transgender.
Since the petitioners met all the requirements under the Act, the Court directed the authority to issue the certificate of eligibility.
SIGNIFICANCE
The judgment reinforced the right of the petitioner as a woman with an intersex condition (CAIS and 46 XY karyotype) to avail gestational surrogacy as a woman. The Centre’s view that transgender people cannot access surrogacy does not apply to women with intersex conditions. However, the Act does not address the broader rights of other intersex persons or transgender persons to access surrogacy.