< Back to other cases

ANUSHKA PRIYADARSHINI V. THE REGISTRAR, DELHI UNIVERSITY

Read the full judgement here
citation:

CASE 15758/1032/2024

court:

COURT OF THE CHIEF COMMISSIONER FOR PERSONS WITH DISABILITY

judges:

COMMISSIONER S. GOVINDARAJ

ISSUE

Whether a transgender intersex woman with benchmark disabilities is entitled to hostel accommodation? And whether a women’s college can personally verify her gender on the campus?

KEY FACTS

The complainant, Mx. Anushka Priyadarshini, received admission at Miranda House, Delhi University. She self-identified as a woman and has intersex characteristics. She also has a disability card for having 48% intellectual disability.

Anushka applied for hostel accommodation, but was denied despite her disability and her high rank in the entrance test. Hostels for persons with disabilities (PwD) were allocated on priority to students with severe locomotor or visual disabilities. Miranda House had already allocated 5% of hostel spots as per the reservations required under the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 (‘RPwD Act’) and Anushka was not included.

Further, on orientation day, Anushka was asked to verify her gender identity at multiple instances on the campus by various members of the college administration. Miranda House asserted that Anushka had not given them her ‘complete’ gender details and it was a women’s college.

DECISION & REASONING

The Court held that Miranda College and Delhi University had engaged in systematic and hostile discrimination against the complainant. The Court ordered them to readmit Anushka.

The Court held that the RPwD Act only set a minimum threshold of 5% reservations. All PwD students are entitled to reasonable accommodation. Miranda House was required to take Anushka’s intersectional identity as a transgender PwD into account and allocate her a hostel beyond the mandatory 5%.

The Court also held that the University and College do not have the authority to verify Anushka’s self-perceived gender identity repeatedly on the campus. If there was a genuine doubt regarding her identity, it must be done through the Equal Opportunity Cell and rely on statutory documents rather than personal confrontations. Notably, the Court held that according to the University’s Policy for Transgender Students, Anushka was entitled to free education and concessions for hostels.

SIGNIFICANCE

The Chief Commissioner’s ruling establishes the need under the RPwD Act to give priority to persons who are discriminated on intersectional grounds. It also clarifies that educational institutions cannot engage in arbitrary physical verification of gender identity. Further, transgender students in Delhi University are entitled to free education and other concessions if they are eligible under its Policy.