< Back to other cases

AARTI MALHOTRA V. UNION OF INDIA

Read the full judgement here
citation:

2026:PHHC:192847

court:

PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT

judges:

JUSTICE MANISHA BATRA

ISSUE

Whether the Court can lay down guidelines to prevent the bullying and harassment of LGBTQIA+ students in educational institutions?

KEY FACTS

The petitioner, Aarti Malhotra, is a single mother who taught at a school in Faridabad. Her son who studied in the same school was bullied for being ‘effeminate’ based on his perceived sexual orientation. This allegedly included sexual assault, physical abuse, humiliation and cyber-bullying. He was also diagnosed with depression and panic attacks from post-tramautic stress. However, the school took no action on complaints Aarti had filed against her son’s bullies and abusers. In 2022, he died by suicide, leaving a note that named the Headmistress and the school authorities. An FIR was registered for abetement of suicide and offences under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012.

Aarti approached the High Court seeking monitoring of the investigation, and guidelines to prevent the harassment of LGBTQIA+ students in schools and colleges across the country. The police filed its investigation report during the course of the proceedings.

DECISION

The Court noted that a superior court cannot monitor an investigation once the charge-sheet is filed. Since the police has already filed a report, the Court left it open for Aarti to raise any deficiencies in the investigation before the trial court.

On the matter of guidelines, the Court noted that this was a matter of the right to life and dignity for school children. However, it was a matter for the executive and expert bodies unless there was a policy vacuum. The Court noted existing policies by the CBSE, Union and NCERT. Most importantly, the Supreme Court has issued binding guidelines when dealing with the student suicides more broadly in Sukdeb Saha v. State of Andhra Pradesh. This included training of all school staff to deal sensitively with LGBTQ+ students and a confidential mechanism and internal committee for complaints of bullying on the basis of gender and sexual orientation. It also treats institutional neglect that contributes to a student’s suicide as institutional culpability.

The Court identified implementation as the problem. It directed the Haryana government to ensure all schools comply with the Sukdeb Saha guidelines and expressly cover bullying on the basis of gender identity and sexual orientation. It directed CBSE to call for and scrutinise annual reports from its affiliated schools in Haryana. Finally, it directed the Union to consider Aarti’s suggestions on counsellor ratios, training of counsellors and curricular sensitisation.

SIGNIFICANCE

The judgment required school complaint mechanisms in Haryana to expressly cover bullying on the basis of gender identity and sexual orientation, treating the enforcement of the Sukdeb Saha guidelines as part of a child’s right under Article 21 to a safe school. It declined, however, to frame fresh guidelines for LGBTQIA+ students and left gender-neutral facilities and curricular change to the executive.