ISSUE
Whether accused persons charged with abducting, assaulting and sexually abusing a transgender person can be granted bail based on a compromise with the complainant?
KEY FACTS
The complainant, Mehboob @ Zamrud, accused the petitioners, Fazal Amin and others, of abducting a transgender person, Anmol, severely beating her and sexually assaulting her. After her recovery, Anmol provided two statements confirming these details. The accused were charged with provisions under the Pakistan Penal Code, 1860 including kidnap, robbery and committing an ‘unnatural offence’ under section 377. The petitioners i.e. the accused, claimed they were falsely implicated and had settled the matter with the complainant, who had no objection to their release. They approached the Peshawar High Court seeking bail.
DECISION & REASONING
The Court noted that the victim, Anmol, had directly named the petitioners and that her medical report supported the prosecution’s version. The Court particularly observed that transgender persons mostly belong to the poor and vulnerable sections of society. Anmol’s statement alleged her cruel treatment was because of her gender. The Court held that the compromise carried no weight at the bail stage, since the offences charged were not compoundable. On a tentative assessment of the record, the petitioners were prima facie connected with the offence. Since it attracted a serious sentence, bail should be denied under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898. The bail petition was therefore denied.
SIGNIFICANCE
The order reaffirmed that a private compromise cannot secure bail in non-compoundable offences. The Court’s recognition of the vulnerability of transgender persons shows judicial awareness of violence directed at them. It noted this crime as an ‘affront to the collective morality of society’.