< Back to other cases

JANVIN CLEETUS V. UNION OF INDIA

Read the full judgement here
citation:

2025:KER:86180 | WP(C) 33642/2024

court:

KERALA HIGH COURT

judges:

JUSTICE N. NAGARESH

ISSUE

Whether the refusal to enrol Janvin Cleetus, a transgender person, in the National Cadet Corps (NCC) violates his fundamental rights under Articles 14, 15, 19 and 21 of the Constitution?

KEY FACTS

The Petitioner, Janvin Cleetus, is a transgender person. He applied for the NCC and satisfied all eligibility conditions. During his interview, it came to the NCC’s notice that he was ‘transgender’. The NCC informed Janvin that he could not be enrolled in the NCC. Section 6 of the NCC Act, 1948 provides for a Senior and Junior Division for students of the ‘male sex’, and a Girls Division for students of the ‘female sex’.  The NCC argued that there was no provision made for transgender persons. Janvin approached the Kerala High Court against his exclusion.

DECISION & REASONING

The Court noted that the NCC was created for students to mirror the training in the Armed Forces. This involves close physical contact and camps with confined accommodation. The Court held that in such conditions, gender-segregated divisions are justified because it’s an important aspect for cadets’ overall well-being and safety. This did not violate the fundamental right to equality.

The Court acknowledged that ideally transgender students should also get an equal opportunity to receive NCC training. However, the formation of a separate NCC Transgender Division would require a sufficient number of transgender students. This is a matter of policy that requires a study by the executive and legislative intervention. So, the Court dismissed Janvin’s petition.

The Court forwarded copies of the judgment to the Ministry of Defence and the Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India, to consider any action that may be necessary.

SIGNIFICANCE

The judgment highlights the limitations of the existing statutory framework governing enrolment in the NCC, which does not provide for the inclusion of transgender persons. This issue was also raised in the case of Hina Haneefa v. State of Kerala in which a transgender woman was admitted to the girls’ division. While the Court was unable to order Janvin’s inclusion as a transgender person, it requests the Union Government to look into the issue.

Note: This uses he/him pronouns and ‘transgender’ as Janvin’s gender identity based on the judgment.