ISSUE
Whether the rules for reservations in law courses in Telangana are unconstitutional for failing to provide horizontal reservations for transgender persons?
KEY FACTS
The petitioners, Sirra Santhosh and Mallula Nagasri sought admission to the LLB/BL course to study law. However, Rule 7 of the Rules of Reservations for Admission to Telangana Law Courses (Regulation of Admission into 3 year and 5 year LLB/B.L. Courses through Common Entrance Test) Rules, 2006 (‘Reservation Rules, 2006’) do not provide for any horizontal reservations for transgender persons. Sirra and Mallula challenged the Rule for this omission. This would allow transgender persons to receive the benefit of reservations within their caste reservation categories instead of being treated on par with others in their caste category.
DECISION & REASONING
In interim orders passed in August 2024, the Court found that the Reservations Rules 2006 did not provide for horizontal reservation for transgender persons. Relying on NALSA v. Union of India, the Court directed the authorities to treat Sirra and Mallula as transgender candidates, and provide them with admission to the LLB/BL course. So, two seats were reserved for them on the course.
The state informed the court that Sirra and Mallula would be admitted to the course on merit in the second round of counselling. The Court directed the authorities ‘accord the benefit of horizontal reservation’ to them and admit them on merit. Since their grievance was resolved, the Court did not make a decision on the validity of the Reservation Rules, 2006.
SIGNIFICANCE
In effect, the Court held that transgender persons are entitled to horizontal resrvations within their individual caste categories. However, since the Court did not adjudicate on the Rule’s validity, the impact of the Court’s interpretation remains confined to the case of Sirra and Mallula.