< Back to other cases

RAKSHIKA RAJ V. STATE OF TAMIL NADU

Read the full judgement here
citation:

WP 6967/2022

court:

MADRAS HIGH COURT

judges:

JUSTICE G.K. ILANTHIRAIYAN

ISSUE

Whether the State can provide reservation to transgender persons by listing them as a caste within the Most Backward Classes category, instead of granting horizontal reservation on the basis of their gender identity?

KEY FACTS

The petitioner, Rakshika Raj, is a transgender woman and a qualified nurse. She is from a Scheduled Caste (SC) and is registered with the Tamil Nadu Transgender Welfare Board. In 2015, the state government issued a government order adding ‘Transgender or Eunuch (Thirunangai or Aravani)’ to the list of Most Backward Classes (‘MBC’). The MBC list mostly includes groups based on caste, and results in a vertical model of reservation. A later order in 2017 clarified that transgender persons holding a SC or other caste certificate can be considered under that category, instead of MBC as a transgender person. Rakshika challenged the 2015 order, arguing that it effectively treated gender identity as a caste.

DECISION

The Court relied on NALSA v. Union of India which recognised transgender identity as a gender identity. It held that placing them under the MBC category required people like Rakshika  to give up her protections as an SC person in order to assert her transgender identity. The Court recognised that reservations must acknowledge that a transgender Dalit person may face worse discrimination than an upper caste transgender person because of the intersection of gender and caste.

The 2017 government order still clubs transgender persons with men for the purpose of reservation. Women have horizontal reservations, but transgender persons are not given any recognition as a separate gender identity.

So, the Court held that the 2015 government order violated the right to equality and was manifestly arbitrary. The court quashed the order and directed the state to provide horizontal reservations to transgender persons within 12 weeks.

SIGNIFICANCE

The judgment affirmed that transgender identity is a gender identity and not a caste, so reservation for transgender persons must cut horizontally across caste categories as it does for women. It recognised the intersection of caste and gender identity, ensuring that transgender persons need not give up caste-based protections to have their gender identity recognised. As of November 2025, the judgment was stayed on appeal to two-judge bench of the High Court.