ISSUE
Whether the Gender Equality Bill can be passed as an ordinary law and is consistent with the Constitution of Sri Lanka?
KEY FACTS
The Sri Lanka Government introduced a Bill titled “Gender Equality Act, No. of 2024” (‘the Bill’) in Parliament on 7th May 2024. The Bill seeks to implement a national policy on gender equality and women empowerment. It would create mechanisms including Gender Equality Council and gender focal points to issue directions and policies to achieve equality and tackled discrimination.
The Sri Lankan Constitution allows anyone to request a special determination from the Supreme Court on Bills within 2 weeks of its introduction in Parliament. On 21st May 2024, two petitions filed by the All Ceylon Buddhist Congress and a group of senior Buddhist monks challenged this Bill. They argued that it was inconsistent with parts of the Constitution.
On 28th May 2025, the heads of iProbono and EQUAL GROUND, who work for LGBTQIA+ communities, filed petitions for intervention. They wanted to argue that the Bill was consistent with the Constitution.
DECISION & REASONING
As a preliminary issue, the Court held that it could not hear the interventions of the heads of iProbono and EQUAL GROUND. Their petitions were filed after the two week time limit for special determination petitions.
The Court noted that the national policy on gender equality and empowerment of women was not enacted law. Therefore, the Government cannot justify the Bill as implementing the policy. It was arbitrary and violated the rule of law.
The Court also found that Article 12 of the Constitution protects against discrimination on the ground of ‘sex’. It allows for ‘special provision’ for the ’empowerment of women’. The Constitution also protects Buddhism and the freedom of religion under Articles 9 and 10. Further, Article 15 allows for reasonable restrictions on equality, including on the ground of ‘morality’.
However, the Bill uses the term ‘gender’, based on cultural and social norms, which is different from ‘sex’, based on biological criteria. It also includes genders beyond male and female. The Bill attempts to prohibit discrimination on the basis of gender, including in ‘private institutions’, in ‘private and family life’ and has no exceptions.
The Court noted that this would interfere in gendered social and religious practices. For example, cisgender or transgender women and non-binary persons may argue that they should receive admission in male-only Buddhist institutions to train monks (bhikkhu). The Bill could also recognise same-sex marriage which are not recognised in personal religious laws, or require the decriminalisation of same sex intercourse.
Relying on these religious rights and the idea of ‘morality’ in the Consitution’s fundamental rights chapter, the Court held that the Bill was inconsistent with the Constitution. Therefore, to become law, it must pass with 2/3rds majority of Parliament and receive approval in a referendum as an amendment to the Constitution.
SIGNIFICANCE
The judgment marks a regressive step for gender equality and inclusivity, both for cisgender women as well as transgender men, women and gender-diverse persons. It means legislation for transgender rights may have to pass the highest threshold for a constitutional amendment.
The leading opinion of Justice Surasena particularly relies on ideas of ‘morality’ to argue against the decriminalisation of homosexuality and other effects of the law. This departs from the Court’s earlier Special Determination in 2023 which upheld decriminalisation as consistent with the Constitution. Justice Kodagoda’s opinion, however, maintains that persons of all gender identities are entitled to equality and gender equality is in line with the values of the Constitution.